Ask the readers: phones in class
February 24, 2009
Since I got an Android phone for Christmas, I’ve been yammering to anyone who will listen about how cell phones are the great technology equalizer — you can use phones to surf the internet, send email, create podcasts, share photos, as well as, you know, talk to people. Even high-end phones are much less expensive than a decent laptop, and they can fit in your pocket.
Folks in the cell phone industry feel the same way, and that’s why they’d like to see more cell phone use in schools. Matt Richtel of the New York Times deals with the issues of using phones in class in his article, Industry Makes Pitch That Smartphones Belong in Classroom.
Many educators regard students’ cell phones as mobile alert systems that let the teacher know that a student would like some detention, please. Phones also present problems ranging from cheating to increasing potential distractions in class. However, it’s hard to dispute the capabilities and cost-effectiveness of smart phones, even if the people crowing about them the loudest are doing so out of naked self-interest. The article notes that a few schools have decided to try programs in which students are issued phones for educational purposes, with positive results:
“Suzette Kliewer, the teacher who administered the Digital Millennial program at Southwest High School in Jacksonville, N.C., said the phones excited her students and made them collaborate and focus on their studies, even outside of school hours. ‘They took average-level kids and made them into honors-level kids,’ she said.
“But Ms. Kliewer also said that she spent much of her own time at night, and during weekends and holidays, monitoring the students’ phone use and occasionally disconnecting phones remotely when students broke the rules.”
Another drawback, addressed by education and technology analyst Bill Rust, is that while smart phones can do a lot, the large screens and keyboards found on computers offer an advantage that phones simply can’t overcome. If you’ve ever written a lengthy email on your phone, even if it has a keypad, you know what he means.
As the benefits of smart phones become more…well, beneficial, will schools loosen their rules on phone usage in class? What’s your school’s cell phone policy? Are you doing anything with phones in class? If that’s not allowed, are you doing anything to try to change the policy? Tell us about it in the comments. -BILL FERRIS
Industry Makes Pitch That Smartphones Belong in Classroom via the New York Times
Related stuff:
The new essentials: Top 10 school supplies for today’s students
How to use your cell phone for education: Pictures and video
These kids nowadays with their dang cell phones! They got their Jonas Brothers and Miley Ray Cyrus ringtones. GET OFF MY LAWN! Sorry for the worn-out shtick complaining about kids nowadays. Tell me a better way to open on the subject of new cell-phone trends and I’ll use it.
Pencils? Check.
Before you confiscate your students’ phones this year, take a look at these posts to see if you can put those little devices to work in your classroom.
You may 
Okay, so you know 
I know, we’ve all seen ugly examples of cell phones being used to 
Sure, your phone plays music, surfs the Web, sends email, and has GPS capability (and you can, you know, talk to people with it, too). That stuff is cool, don’t get me wrong, but we’ve only scratched the surface of what these handheld powerhouses can do. Now, with one simple download, you can give your phone some extra power you can use in the classroom thanks to 
So let’s be honest, most of us can’t afford fancy digital video cameras, and if even we could, we wouldn’t carry them around all the time. That’s why whenever something exciting happens, everyone whips out their trusty cell phone cameras in order to document it. The problem, however, is that they are phones first, and video cameras second (or third, or fourth), so the quality is generally lacking, especially in the resolution department.
